If you’re searching for all-you-can-eat sushi in Chicago, you probably want two answers before anything else: what does it cost, and what do you actually get? At Koi Sushi in Lincoln Park, all-you-can-eat lunch is $24.99 per person, Monday–Friday until 3:30 PM (holidays excluded). Dinner is $32.99 per person, and on Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays the dinner price applies all day. That flat price covers the full all-you-can-eat menu — signature rolls, nigiri, appetizers, ramen, and udon — plus a free self-serve bar that most AYCE spots don’t include at all. Below is an honest breakdown of what’s included, and the order strategy regulars use to get full value out of the ticket. (Full overview: our all-you-can-eat sushi guide)

What the price actually includes

The AYCE menu runs to more than 130 items: 25 signature rolls, 28 kinds of nigiri (ordered one piece at a time, so you can sample widely), 21 appetizers, salads and soups, five ramens and five udons, plus regular rolls, hand rolls, and a full vegetarian section. Nothing on that list is a “lite” version — these are the same rolls sold à la carte elsewhere on the menu, like the Godzilla Roll and the Pink Lady at $15 each.

Assorted signature sushi rolls on a plate at Koi Sushi in Lincoln Park, Chicago

Then there’s the part people don’t expect: the self-serve bar is free for every guest. It has two slushy flavors, four rotating drinks, desserts you can take yourself, and a soft-serve ice cream station. It’s included in the AYCE price, and it’s open to à-la-carte guests too. Treat it as your drinks-and-dessert course rather than an afterthought — that’s real money you don’t spend on top of the ticket.

Sushi boat loaded with assorted signature rolls at Koi Sushi in Lincoln Park, Chicago

How to order so the math works in your favor

Start with the signature rolls. This is where the value is. À la carte, the Godzilla (deep-fried shrimp, crab, cream cheese, and avocado under spicy and eel sauce), the Volcano, and the MVP each cost $15. Two signature rolls ordered on their own would already run about $30 — more than the entire $24.99 lunch. Open with one or two of those, not with the cheapest items on the menu.

Use nigiri to explore. Because nigiri is ordered piece by piece, it’s the lowest-risk way to try things you’re unsure about. Go for the pieces that cost the most à la carte — scallop, salmon roe, eel, seared scallop — and skip nothing you genuinely like just because it’s “only” $2 a piece on paper.

Pace yourself with appetizers, and don’t lead with rice. Takoyaki, Crab Rangoon, Jalapeño Bomb, and the Koi Pizza (a crispy sushi-rice crust topped with spicy tuna) are small, shareable, and don’t fill you up the way a table full of regular rolls will in the first ten minutes. Save the rice-heavy standards for later rounds, if you still want them.

Order in rounds, and finish what you order. This is the one rule that matters. Seating is limited to two hours, and the house charges for leftovers — $1 per piece for appetizers, nigiri, sashimi, and signature rolls; $0.50 per piece for regular rolls; $3 per hand roll — rice included. The strategy that works: order a round, finish it, then order the next. You’ll eat more of what you actually want, and the bill stays exactly $24.99 (or $32.99) plus tax.

Save room for the bar. Mochi ice cream, macarons, pudding, tempura banana, and the soft-serve station are part of the deal (a few desserts are limited to one piece per person). If you fill up entirely on rolls, you’re leaving part of what you paid for on the table.

Lunch vs. dinner: the $8 question

The only difference between the two tickets is timing. If your schedule is flexible, the weekday lunch before 3:30 PM is simply the best-value seat in the house — the same kitchen, the same menu, $8 less. Evenings and weekends run at the $32.99 dinner price, which is still easy to come out ahead on if you follow the order above. One heads-up for groups: parties of five or more have an 18% service charge added automatically, which is standard practice and worth knowing before a big birthday table does the math. Planning a celebration? See birthday parties at Koi Sushi.

Who this is a great deal for — and who should skip it

Great deal if: you have a real appetite; you’re feeding a group with mixed tastes (the menu has plenty of cooked rolls, ramen, and udon for anyone who doesn’t eat raw fish); or you like trying ten different rolls instead of committing to two.

Order à la carte instead if: you’re a light eater. Two regular rolls run $5–$10 each and a plain ramen is $9.99, so a small appetite will spend less ordering normally — and the self-serve bar is still free. Likewise, if you only want one specific premium roll and a drink, a single $15 signature roll beats a $32.99 ticket. AYCE rewards variety and appetite; it isn’t a discount on a small meal. (New to the neighborhood? More on eating in the area: sushi in Lincoln Park)

FAQ

How much is all-you-can-eat sushi at Koi Sushi?

Lunch is $24.99 per person, Monday–Friday until 3:30 PM, except holidays. Dinner is $32.99 per person, and on Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays the dinner price applies all day. Kids are priced by age: ages 3–5 $10.99, ages 6–9 $14.99, and ages 10–12 $18.99.

What is included in the AYCE price besides sushi?

The whole AYCE menu — appetizers, salads, soups, five ramens, five udons, regular and vegetarian rolls, and desserts — plus the free self-serve bar with two slushies, four rotating drinks, take-your-own desserts, and a soft-serve ice cream station.

Is there a time limit or a charge for leftovers?

Yes to both. Seating is limited to two hours, last orders go in 15 minutes before closing, and leftovers are charged per piece ($1 for appetizers, nigiri, sashimi, and signature rolls; $0.50 for regular rolls; $3 for hand rolls). Ordering in rounds is the easy way to avoid it.

Does Koi Sushi have parking?

Yes — free street parking is available on Southport Ave, a short walk from the door. In Lincoln Park, that’s worth factoring into the “deal” all by itself.

Visit Koi Sushi

Koi Sushi is at 2156 N Clybourn Ave, Chicago, IL 60614, open Sunday–Thursday 12:00–9:45 PM and Friday–Saturday 12:00–10:45 PM. Walk-ins are welcome; for a big table, call (773) 904-8144. Taking food home instead? Order directly through our website or by phone and get 10% off pickup — no third-party markup, same kitchen.